How to Train Your Dragon was very entertaining, but at the same time I knew it was going to be entertaining, and so I wasn't blown away by this book. It's a fun and vivid idea brought to life in a catchy, "Forget which page you're on," "Sad when it's over" kinda way. However, as cool and original as the story is I almost wish I could see it presented in a less "Child oriented" fashion, at the same time I don't know if that would take away some of its cartoony appeal.
The movie, which I must have seen at least a dozen times now, was one of my all time favorite animated films, and that's saying something... my sister works for Pixar. I feel like the book, (though great) didn't quite live up to the epicness I found in the movie. All this being said when I look for the reason I feel it fell short I can never quite put my finger on it. There is no definite moment of "Ah ha!!! this is why!!" and that bugs me to some extent. If you go back through all of what I've written here I think you'll find I've really said surprisingly little, and I think the reason behind this is that everything I want to say about this book can be summed up relatively simply.
Its a fantastic children's book, but If you're over the age of 13 you'll probably enjoy the movie more, and if your experience is the same as mine, the movie will last longer.
Sunday, April 24, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

3 comments:
When readying over you post i felt the exact same way while watching the movie. I think that the reason that the book fell short of the movie is because the movie had a serious overriding conflict of the village needing to protect themselves from the dragons. The book was more of a story without a central conflict until the dragons on the beach. This way might be more appealing to children, and the main conflict in the movie and way they overcame it is more tuned to the senses of people of our age group.
I enjoyed both the movie and the book. I thought the book was great and it was cool how the dragon was smaller and not a typical dragon. Everything in the book was different then the way a normal story is. A hero had a big pretty horse or a big dragon, etc. In this story the dragon was very small and didn't even listen to Hiccupp. I did like how in the movie toothless did form a friendship with Hiccupp, that was sweet. I loved their bond in the movie.
Overall I thought both the book and the movie were very good.
I agree with Matthew on this. I felt that the movie was a little childish at times but if you look at it with a different prospective, that's what made it good. The movie was better than the book in my opinion. However, both of them were both enjoyable.
Post a Comment